‘198 BIRDS the nightingale, who got nineteen for everything but sprightliness ; in that particular he only got fourteen, being easily beaten by the skylark, the goldfinch, and the canary ; in mellowness he was equalled: by the blackcap, in plaintiveness by the solitary thrush, which was perhaps the ring-ouzel, in compass by the canary, and in execution also by the canary. Second THE BLACKCAP on the list to him in total number of marks was the linnet, the canary coming third and the blackcap fourth. Absurd as the proceeding may appear, the result curiously confirmed the popular verdict. Everywhere the chief song-birds are found among the thrush and nightingale group, and everywhere the