260 REYNARD THE FOX Goat.’ The Reynard occurs earliest in Petrus Alfonsi, and was probably derived from the East. P. 212. Foul dismal hole. In Ren. br. XIV. the wolf eats his fill and becomes too fat:to get out again. CHAPTER XXIII P. 215. Challenge. ‘Trial by battle was of course the final resource during the Middle Ages in cases like the present, where there was a conflict of evidence. CHAPTERS XXIV-V P. 224. The Combat. en. br. VI., Caxton, chap. XXXIX. THE END Printed by R. & R. Crark, Limiren, Edinburgh.