Brooks: Diplomacy and the Borderlads 201 SFrank W. Hackett, The Meade ClaiM (Washington, 1910); see AS.P, p., IV:144-155, 704-786. Edwin M. Borhard, in Diplomatio Protectio of Citivess Abroad (New York, 1915), pp. 889-890, disease the injustice of ruling out the Meade claim John B. Moore, History and Digest of Isternational Arbitrations (Wash- ington, 1898), V:4487-4518. Ibid., pp. 4519-458L See A.H.N., Et 5 57 Expediente on French claims. SMiller, Treaties, 11:405-420. SOharles O. Paullin, Atlas of the Historica Geography of the United States (Washington and New York, 1982), p. 20 and plate 89. "162 U.S. Reports (1896) 1-91; 256 U.. Reports (1921) 70-93, 602-610; Isaiah Bowman, "An American Boundary Dispute," Geographical Beiew, XIII (1928):161-189. "John H. Latan6, History of America Foreign Policy (new ed., New York, 1984), p. 119. SPhilip C. Brooks, "The Paeii Coast's First International Boundary De- lineation, 1816-1819," Pacifo Historical Beiew, III (1934):62-79. SGallatin (minister to Great Britain) to Clay (secretary of state), Decem- ber 2, 1826, in A.S.P., F.., VI: 655-656. SClay to Gallatin, June 19, 1826, and February 24, 1827, ibid., pp. 644- 647. Ellen 0. Semple, Amerioan History and Its Geographic Condition (New York, 1908), p. 80L Frederick Merk, in "The Oregon Pioneers and the Boundary," Amerians Historical Bevie, XXIX (1924):681-699, clearly shows that only the region between the Columbia and the Forty-ninth Parallel was really in contest in 1846, appreciably diminishing the diplomatic iganieance of the pioneer settle- ment south of that river. The English relinquishment of the region south of the Columbia, however, shows that England maintained no claim beyond the south- ern limit of Oregon set by the treaty of 1819. And the fact still remains that the pioneers, encouraged by the strengthening of the United States' title in that treaty, put the area between the Forty-second Parallel and the Columbia beyond diplomatic bargaining. Samuel F. Bemis, Pisn eey's Treaty: A Study of Amerisa's Advantage from Europe's Distress, 1783-1800 (Baltimore, 1926).