WHO STOLE THE MUTTON? 165 Now, Billy thought this accusation the more likely to be true, in that Jack, who of course was totally unused to a sailor's hard fare, had openly complained of the hardship of having salt beef continually for dinner, and had demanded some fresh meat in a rather impatient manner the day before. And now Jack's assurances that he had not touched the meat, but had found the dish empty, were not credited; and finding the worst was being believed of him, the old dogged and obstinate look came to his face, and he sullenly determined to defend himself no longer. His silence exasperated the hot-tempered cook still more, and his voice and accusations became louder and louder, until at last they were overheard by the first mate, who, having finished his smoke, was unfortunately passing near. "What has the young rascal been at now?" he asked Billy, with an ominous frown coming over his countenance. The cook started; he had not known of the mate being near, and though irritated at Jack's supposed theft, he was far from desiring that the boy should fall into the hands of this cruel man. So he muttered something about having had to give him "a rowing," and it being "all right" now, until the mate forced him to explain matters in full.