especially important to copper mining where new methods of concentration such as the flotation process, intro- duced in the United States in earnest after 1910, permitted the working of very low-grade copper ores. In this process, ores were finely ground and put into an oily liquid bath. Air was then let into the bottom of the container, and oily bubbles collected the metal, which had an affinity for the oil, and brought it to the surface in the form of a froth; non-metallic material remained behind as sediment. The second major advance, open pit mining, eliminated the need for underground lighting and ventilation, for expensive timbering, and the other high cost operations and paraphernalia required in underground mining. The introduction of open pit, non-selective mining techniques, coupled with the introduction of the flotation process, permitted extensive but low-grade copper deposits to be mined at reasonably low cost; changing techniques in mining and refining were complementary. In iron mining, too, open pit operations greatly increased productivity. The unique feature of Mesabi ore in particular was its softness and proximity to the surface where it could be "mined" with steam shovels. Thus, it was not only the great extent of the rich ore deposits that made the Mesabi so valuable; their closeness to the surface made them more valuable still.