72 The higher rates of growth of metals in use than of apparent consumption are to be expected. Stocks of metals in use would increase even if annual additions to the stocks (apparent consumption) were to remain exactly the same for each successive year. Growth rates of annual apparent consumption represent what is, in effect, the first derivative of the rate of growth of stocks of metals in use, to which growth in GNP is more directly related. Comparing rates of growth in GNP to rates of growth in apparent consumption of metals has caused metals to have been viewed as less important than they actually have been. While rates of growth in annual production and apparent consumption of metals can be compared only indirectly to the rate of growth in GNP, these rates of growth are important insofar as they reflect demands made upon resources; the higher the rates of withdrawal, the more rapid is the decline in the quality of metals resources that remain, and the more difficult is their acquisition. On the other hand, the greater is the amount of value generated by production per ton of metal, the greater is the value of production that can be obtained from the use of any given metals supply. Mining and metals resources will be considered in the next chapter, but increased efficiency of metals can be considered here.