45 bent, and planed. That material was steel, but a cheap method of production and one which allowed greater volume had to be found. Jn Pennsylvania, William Kelley, an iron worker, noticing that a piece of iron in his furnace had become extremely hot, apparently without benefit of fuel, concluded that steel might be made directly from iron, using only air as fuel; oxygen in the air, when combined with carbon in the iron, would burn away the carbon and, hence, produce steel. An initial experiment in 1847 failed, but a similar experiment in 1850 yielded much different results. "We saw a middling-sized vessel," said one observer, "that had a mouth open on one side and near the top. The whole was shaped something like an egg, only bigger than a barrel. We saw molten iron poured into the vessel. Then, Kelley he turned on a blast of cold air, blown from a rig he had devised himself. The vessel set up a large noise, a roaring like you dont often hear, and fire belched furiously from its mouth, making many colors. But only for a few minutes. The noise and fire died down. We then saw a blacksmith take a small part of the iron, which had cooled, and with a merry ring of his hammer, he contrived and threw at the feet of the amazed spectators, a perfect horse shoe. . . next, the smith took some more of the cooled metal, made it into nails forthwith, and shod the horse of one in the crowd."(27) Kelley unfortunately neglected to patent his process until 1856, by which time the famous Englishman, Henry Bessemer, had arrived on the scene with essentially 27 Stewart H. Holbrook, Iron Brew, A Century of American Ore and Steel (New York: Macmillan Company, 19Uo) p. 188.